I'm New to Grace Presbyterian Church

We are so glad you are interested in Grace Church. If you decide to visit this Sunday, we think you will find us to be a cross-section of our community here on the East End of Long Island. We are normal people who are being changed by the grace of God, and who are learning more and more each week about what it looks like to be a follower of Jesus Christ. But you don’t need to be a follower of Jesus to find a place here. In fact, come with your doubts and questions; you surely are welcome. And if you are a follower of Christ, we look forward to meeting you and encouraging you in your faith.


Our Pastor

Our pastor is Rev. Mark Middlekauff. He, his wife and three daughters moved to the East End in 2006 to plant Grace Presbyterian Church. He was not raised in a Christian home and was an atheist for most of his 20’s. After coming to faith at 29 years of age he followed a calling into ministry. Rev. Middlekauff holds an undergraduate degree from Indiana University and a Master of Divinity from Covenant Theological Seminary.


Our Location

Grace Presbyterian Church is located in a perfect spot in the Hamptons in the community of Water Mill. Our address is 1225 Montauk Highway, Water Mill, NY 11976. We are on the northeast corner of Montauk Highway and Scuttle Hole Road. Here is a MAP.


Our Service Time

We gather for weekly worship on Sundays at 10:00 AM. Our service ends around 11:15, but many people hang out after the service to enjoy coffee and tea and conversation.


Our Child Care

We have a wonderful nursery and a fantastic children’s Sunday school program. If you have infants and toddlers up through age 3, you may drop them off in the nursery when you arrive. If you have pre-K through six grade kids, they will join the adult is the worship service until they are dismissed during the announcements. After the worship service is over, parents will need to sign their children out of their classrooms.


Our Worship Service Style

Our worship service is a blend of traditional and contemporary. Our music emphasizes rich, theological lyrics with a dynamic band featuring beautiful vocals, piano, guitar, bass, drums and an occasional mandolin or cello. Preaching aims at bringing Scripture alive in our postmodern culture and magnifying God’s grace towards us in his son, Jesus Christ. We serve the Lord’s Supper every Sunday.


2017 Grace Camp

2017 GraceCamp: Extreme Survival

 Guys Day Out - Surfing

Guys Day Out - Surfing


Thanksgiving Service Project

Thanksgiving Service Project